The Criterion for the Materialistic anti-ID position

In my many years of discussing evolutionism, Creation and ID, I have asked on many occassions "What is the criteria for determining the obvious "apparent" design observed in living organisms and the universe?"

IOW I am interested in what is the data that supports the materialistic anti-ID position.

For all my asking I have never received a straight answer. And with all the negative attacks the materialists hurl at Creation and ID, it became obvious that there is only one criterion:

Flat out refuse to accept an intelligent agency was responsible no matter what data is presented.

So there you have it. The materialistic anti-ID position is intellectually bankrupt and as unobjective as one can get.